Choosing the Right KPIs for better Decision-Making

Working with goal management and KPI (key performance indicator) reporting is essential for improving the performance and results of your online business. But how should goals be set? And how do you choose the most important KPIs?

In e-commerce, data floods in from every direction – customer service, Google Analytics, ads, and reviews. As an e-commerce manager, online marketing coordinator, or anyone overseeing online performance and marketing budgets, you’re likely swamped with reports measuring everything from clicks to customer sentiment. 

With so much data, it’s easy to lose track of what matters. How do you know what’s working? Which metrics deserve your focus? 

This is where goal management and KPI reporting come in. By identifying the most critical data, you gain clarity on what’s driving success – and what’s holding you back.  

To reach your goals, you need clear objectives, reliable metrics, and a strategic dashboard. Your goals are the destination, objectives are the waypoints, and KPIs are the instruments that keep you on course. 

But here’s the challenge: many businesses choose KPIs that seem important but lack a connection to real objectives. As a result, they track metrics that lead them in circles. 

Building Your Cockpit

To truly benefit from KPI reporting, start with your business goals. Are you aiming to increase revenue, strengthen brand loyalty, or improve processes? Once you know where you want to go, you can define objectives and select KPIs that serve as true indicators of progress. 

Imagine your business as an aircraft. Pilots rely on their cockpit instruments to make informed decisions in real-time. Similarly, your digital business needs a well-constructed cockpit – a strategic dashboard that shows, at a glance, whether you’re soaring or stalling. 

But a cockpit cluttered with irrelevant dials is more dangerous than helpful. That’s why choosing the right KPIs is essential. The right KPIs provide clarity and insight. They highlight what’s working and, equally important, what isn’t.  

WHAT’S A GOOD KPI?

A good KPI is like a trustworthy co-pilot. It supports your business objectives, prompts action, and is easy to understand. Let’s break it down: 

#1
Supports the Business Objectives

Every KPI should tie directly to your broader goals. If your goal is to increase revenue, KPIs like “conversion rate” or “average order value” make sense. If it doesn’t align with a goal, it’s just a vanity metric.

#2
Defined with Management

KPIs should be agreed upon by decision-makers. When management is involved, KPIs are more likely to lead to action rather than gathering dust in a report.

#3
Leads to Action

A good KPI isn’t just a number; it’s a call to action. If a KPI shows poor performance, it should spark a conversation: “What’s causing this? What can we change?”

#4
Data-Driven

KPIs should be based on reliable, measurable data. Gut feelings won’t help you steer through the storm. 

#5
Easy to Understand

Everyone on the team should understand the KPI measures and why it matters. Simplicity keeps everyone aligned.

SPOT THE DIFFERENCE BETWEEN KPIS AND MEASUREMENT POINTS 

KPIs should be distinguished from measurement points. Many people confuse KPIs with measurement points, which makes it all the more difficult to build a well-defined cockpit.

Broadly speaking, while a KPI indicates whether an organisation is on track to achieve its goals, measurement points explain why things are going well or poorly. A KPI shows whether action is needed, while a measurement point indicates what needs to be addressed. 

For example, if your KPI is “conversion rate,” measurement points might include “page load time,” “bounce rate,” or “purchase funnel performance.” The KPI tells you there’s a problem; the measurement points help you diagnose it. 

HOW DO YOU CHOOSE THE RIGHT KPIs? 

Selecting the right KPIs begins with defining clear business goals. Let’s break it down with some examples: 

Goal 1: Increase Revenue

You could break this goal down into two objectives:

Objective 1: Improve Conversion Rate 

KPI: Conversion Rate (e.g., percentage of website visitors who make a purchase

Measurement Points: Page load time, bounce rate, cart abandonment rate and checkout process efficiency.

Objective 2: Increase Average Order Value (AOV)

KPI: Average Order Value (e.g., average spend per transaction) 

Measurement Points: Items per transaction, upsell and cross-sell rates, discount usage, and product bundling performance.

Goal 2: Strengthen Brand Loyalty

The objective of this goal could be to Boost Customer Retention.

KPI: Customer Retention Rate

Measurement Points: Time between purchases, Net Promoter Score (NPS), email engagement rate, and repeat purchase frequency

Goal 3: Optimise Internal Processes

The objective of this goal could be to Optimise Internal Processes.

KPI: Order Fulfilment Time

Measurement Points: Picking and packing time, inventory accuracy rate, shipping delay rate, and order error rate

The Journey to Clarity and Success 

Choosing the right KPIs isn’t just about metrics – it’s about clarity, strategy, and action. By aligning your goals with meaningful KPIs, you’re equipping your business with the tools to navigate confidently, optimise performance, and achieve success.

Need help defining your KPIs or optimising your strategy?

She’ll help you explore how you can set better goals and choose the right KPIs to drive your business forward.

You might also be interested in...

Articles and guides
Lift your digital B2B strategy with these 5 omnichannel tactics
In an increasingly complex and digitally driven marketplace, B2B businesses must adapt to evolving buyer expectations and tech advancements. The omnichannel strategy, once predominantly associated with direct-to-consumer brands, now offers critical lessons for the B2B sector. And time is of the essence. 
Omnichannel keynotes
Prepare for 2025 with strategies from omnichannel leaders
We've asked eight people from leading brands in various sectors to share their insights on how to succeed in omnichannel commerce in 2024 and beyond.
Articles and guides
3 steps to maximise your Google Ads performance
Are you finding it hard to align your online and offline strategies? Or dealing with separate KPIs and siloed teams? The key to unlocking growth is treating your channels as a united force. By using data from your stores in your performance marketing, you can create a powerful growth engine.
Articles and guides
Crafting excellent user experiences: a guide to seamless design systems
Learn how a unified design system can provide a structured approach for a seamless and user-centric digital experience. Dive into essential considerations, experience principles, and practical tips for successful implementation
Articles and guides
Developing a powerful loyalty programme in 9 steps
Empower your brand with a successful loyalty programme using our 9-step framework, designed to simplify the process of building lasting customer relations.
Articles and guides
Choosing the right resale model for your brand
We’ve put together a comprehensive whitepaper to help guide you in choosing the right resale model for your brand – from selecting the ideal operational model and deciding which products to offer, to choosing the most effective technology and determining fair prices for both sellers and buyers. We’ve got you covered.